Okay, I'm hoping for a little serious discussion, using the forum as a means to keep record of every little detail we can muster. I've been spouting for months how I want to know the secret of how Japanese manga and anime can have such intense stories, or even how the mediocre stories somehow put our western work to shame. It's been discussed that a lot of it has to do with their attention to culture...that they have an almost hierarchical ritual approach to so many aspects of their heritage, the writing and drawing skills are 'handed down.' Maybe not father to son, but master to apprentice. Sensei to grasshopper.
**NOTE:
IF we ever happen to get a few more members and some of them happen to be Japanese, know I am NOT poking fun at you. I am putting my understanding of your creative superiority into my own words.
Okay, fellow forum members who may/may not enjoy a good manga or anime....this is what I'm looking for in this discussion: quick, simple OBSERVATIONS. We can explain theories until the sky falls (little over a year!), and we can drop full page comparisons or thousand word essays. What I want here is an ongoing LIST of things YOU notice that jump out as somehow important 'in your eyes' that makes good manga/anime good. Maybe not things that make it good, but also things that are so obvious to the mystique of it, but many may not know. Again, not deep or LONG discussion. Save that for a rainy day. If you have to use particualr serieses for examples, do so please! I'm hoping, as time goes on we can go from top to bottom in this list, and start to see some form of pattern, or at least learn a few somethings we can start using or concentrating on in our own artworks. Remember, even simple things, like if someone observes a major difference being manga written right to left...put it in here!
If we can get a decent list, and compare the cultural influences against our own history as a culture, maybe we can not only find ways to excel in the genre, but also manage to westernize the genres without bastardizing them! OH, discussion IS okay, just keep it short (like I can't do
).
I will reply to this with an example that I learned a while back, but NEEDS to be in this list because apparently to the Japanese culture this is important. Here we go...
Wed Oct 05, 2011 2:43 pm by Shadowcrunch